Integrated Forensics Approach to Fingerprint PCB Sources Using Rapid Screening Characterization and Advanced Chemical Fingerprinting

ER-200826

Objectives of the Demonstration

Determining the original source of contamination for a heterogeneous matrix such as sediments is a requirement for both cleanup and compliance programs within the military. The technology to be demonstrated includes two primary components: 1) screening technologies that provide for wide spatial and temporal coverage to delineate sediment contaminant heterogeneity in a cost-effective manner and 2) advanced chemical fingerprinting (ACF) on a selected subset of samples to delineate sources. Advanced chemical fingerprinting includes advanced laboratory chemical analysis of samples and the application of sophisticated data analysis and interpretation methods. The overall objective of the project is to provide guidance on integrating chemical techniques into a cost-effective forensics program to apportion regulatory costs among principal responsible parties (PRP).

Back to Top

Technology Description

The demonstration includes two analytical chemistry components that are modified from standard Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) methods, but their integration and use together with innovative data analysis methods in a forensics study are novel and need validation to provide case studies for future site use. Rapid screening characterization (RSC) by SPAWAR Systems Center, San Diego (SSC-SD) of semivolatile organics can be conducted using various commercially available immunoassay test kits. The techniques for the RSC of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB) in sediments have been adapted from methods developed for use in soils. The techniques are modifications of the current standard immunoassay methods described under EPA Method 4020 (Screening for PCBs by Immunoassay) that have been developed at SSC-SD to work on the wet, organic rich matrix found in many sediments. Battelle has in recent years developed state-of-the-art PCB analytical methods using high-resolution gas chromatography and low-resolution mass spectrometry operating in selected ion monitoring mode (HRGC/LRM-SIM), that are highly cost-effective and provide detailed, high-quality, data. The method employs components of EPA Method 680 (HRGC/LRMS PCB homologue and total PCB method) and Method 1668a (HRGC/HRMS PCB congener method). The base methods have been modified to include many nonstandard, environmentally important, and diagnostic PCB congeners that will permit data analysis for differentiating potential sources. PCB forensics data reduction and analysis include various types of statistical and other numerical analyses, including the application of sophisticated receptor modeling methods to help tease out source relationships.

Back to Top

Implementation Issues

Since the cost of remedial efforts in sediment can be very high, the potential cost benefits of the technical approach developed in this project can be significant. For example, initial estimates for sediment cleanup to sediment quality guideline levels in 1998 for Hunters Point Shipyard were $87 million, and it can be projected that by including additional PRPs the military portion of this cost can be significantly reduced. This high cost for only one site has forced the Navy and regulators to reevaluate site studies to develop a more reasonable sediment management scheme. Given the number of additional military sites located in industrial settings that contain PCB contamination, the ability to accurately and defensibly identify additional PRPs would be of great benefit in spreading both cleanup and compliance costs among responsible parties. The current alternative approach without a forensics study merely assumes that the most visible landholder (often a military facility) closest to the sediment contamination is responsible. (Anticipated Project Completion - 2011)

Back to Top

Points of Contact

Principal Investigator

Dr. James Leather

SPAWAR Systems Center

Phone: 619-553-6240

Fax: 619-553-6305

Program Manager

Environmental Restoration

SERDP and ESTCP

Document Types

  • Fact Sheet - Brief project summary with links to related documents and points of contact.
  • Final Report - Comprehensive report for every completed SERDP and ESTCP project that contains all technical results.
  • Cost & Performance Report - Overview of ESTCP demonstration activities, results, and conclusions, standardized to facilitate implementation decisions.
  • Technical Report - Additional interim reports, laboratory reports, demonstration reports, and technology survey reports.
  • Guidance - Instructional information on technical topics such as protocols and user’s guides.
  • Workshop Report - Summary of workshop discussion and findings.
  • Multimedia - On demand videos, animations, and webcasts highlighting featured initiatives or technologies.
  • Model/Software - Computer programs and applications available for download.
  • Database - Digitally organized collection of data available to search and access.